StabilizationUtils: remove pointless bool return values

use return values instead of out-params

Apps/Common/StabilizationUtils.C

@@ -47,47 +47,44 @@ double getTauPt (double dt, double mu, const Vector& U,
 }
 
 
-bool getTauNSPt (double dt, double mu, const Vector& U,
+std::pair<double,double>
-                 const Matrix& G, double &tauM, double& tauC,
+getTauNSPt (double dt, double mu, const Vector& U,
+            const Matrix& G, const double Ct, const double Cl)
+{
+  double tauM = getTauPt(dt,mu,U,G,Ct,Cl);
+  double tauC = 1.0 / (tauM*G.trace());
+
+  return {tauM, tauC};
+}
+
+
+std::pair<double,double>
+getTauNSALEPt (double dt, double mu, const Vector& U,
+               const Matrix& G,
                const double Ct, const double Cl)
 {
-  tauM = getTauPt(dt,mu,U,G,Ct,Cl);
+  double tauM = getTauPt(dt,mu,U,G,Ct,Cl);
-  tauC = 1.0/(tauM*G.trace());
+  double tauC = tauM*(U.dot(U));
-  return true;
+
+  return {tauM, tauC};
 }
 
 
-bool getTauNSALEPt (double dt, double mu, const Vector& U,
+Vector getTauPtJac (const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
-                    const Matrix& G, double & tauM, double& tauC,
+                    const double tauM)
-                    const double Ct, const double Cl)
 {
-  tauM = getTauPt(dt,mu,U,G,Ct,Cl);
+  return -pow(tauM,3)*G*U;
-
-  tauC = tauM*(U.dot(U));
-
-  return true;
 }
 
 
-bool getTauPtJac (const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
+std::pair<Vector,Vector>
-                  const double tauM, Vector& tauMjac)
+getTauNSPtJac (const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
+                    const double tauM, const double& tauC)
 {
-  tauMjac = -pow(tauM,3)*G*U;
+  Vector tauMjac = getTauPtJac(U, G, tauM);
+  Vector tauCjac = (-tauC/tauM) * tauMjac;
 
-  return true;
+  return {tauMjac, tauCjac};
-}
-
-
-bool getTauNSPtJac (const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
-                    const double tauM, const double& tauC,
-                    Vector& tauMjac, Vector& tauCjac)
-{
-  if (!getTauPtJac(U, G, tauM, tauMjac))
-    return false;
-
-  tauCjac = (-tauC/tauM) * tauMjac;
-
-  return true;
 }
 
 }

Apps/Common/StabilizationUtils.h

@@ -40,13 +40,11 @@ namespace StabilizationUtils {
   //! \param[in] mu Diffusion/viscosity parameter
   //! \param[in] U  Velocity vector
   //! \param[in] G  The G matrix
-  //! \param[out] tauM Stabilization parameter for momentum
-  //! \param[out] tauC Stabilization parameter for continuity
   //! \param[in] Ct VMS parameter
   //! \param[in] Cl VMS parameter
-  //! \details Stabilization parameters in integration point
+  //! \return Stabilization parameters in integration point
-  bool getTauNSPt(double dt, double mu, const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
+  std::pair<double,double>
-                  double& tauM, double& tauC,
+  getTauNSPt(double dt, double mu, const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
              const double Ct = 2.0, const double Cl = 36.0);
 
   //! \brief Computes stabilization parameters for Navier-Stokes equations.
@@ -54,31 +52,28 @@ namespace StabilizationUtils {
   //! \param[in] mu Diffusion/viscosity parameter
   //! \param[in] U Velocity vector
   //! \param[in] G The G matrix
-  //! \param[out] tauM Stabilization parameter for momentum
-  //! \param[out] tauC Stabilization parameter for continuity
   //! \param[in] Ct VMS parameter
   //! \param[in] Cl VMS parameter
-  //! \details Stabilization parameters in integration point
+  //! \return Stabilization parameters in integration point
-  bool getTauNSALEPt(double dt, double mu, const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
+  std::pair<double,double>
-                     double& tauM, double& tauC,
+  getTauNSALEPt(double dt, double mu, const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
                 const double Ct = 2.0, const double Cl = 36.0);
 
   //! \brief Computes variation of stability parameters with respect to velocity.
   //! \param[in] U  Velocity vector
   //! \param[in] G  The G matrix
   //! \param[in] tauM Stabilization parameter for momentum
-  //! \param[out] tauMjac Variation of tauM with respect to U
+  Vector getTauPtJac(const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
-  bool getTauPtJac(const Vector& U, const Matrix& G, const double tauM, Vector& tauMjac);
+                   const double tauM);
 
   //! \brief Computes variation of stability parameters with respect to velocity.
   //! \param[in] U  Velocity vector
   //! \param[in] G  The G matrix
   //! \param[in] tauM Stabilization parameter for momentum
   //! \param[in] tauC Stabilization parameter for continuity
-  //! \param[out] tauMjac Variation of tauM with respect to U
+  std::pair<Vector,Vector>
-  //! \param[out] tauCjac Variation of tauC with respect to U
+  getTauNSPtJac(const Vector& U, const Matrix& G,
-  bool getTauNSPtJac(const Vector& U, const Matrix& G, const double tauM,
+                const double tauM, const double& tauC);
-                     const double& tauC, Vector& tauMjac, Vector& tauCjac);
 }
 
 #endif

Apps/Common/Test/TestStabilizationUtils.C

@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ TEST(TestStabilizationUtils, GetTauNSPt)
   utl::getGmat(J, &du[0], G);
 
   double tauM, tauC;
-  ASSERT_TRUE(StabilizationUtils::getTauNSPt(0.1, 0.3, U, G, tauM, tauC));
+  std::tie(tauM,tauC) = StabilizationUtils::getTauNSPt(0.1, 0.3, U, G);
   ASSERT_FLOAT_EQ(tauM, 0.016634906);
   ASSERT_FLOAT_EQ(tauC, 1.87858);
 }
@@ -85,7 +85,7 @@ TEST(TestStabilizationUtils, GetTauNSALEPt)
   utl::getGmat(J, &du[0], G);
 
   double tauM, tauC;
-  ASSERT_TRUE(StabilizationUtils::getTauNSALEPt(0.1, 0.3, U, G, tauM, tauC));
+  std::tie(tauM,tauC) = StabilizationUtils::getTauNSALEPt(0.1, 0.3, U, G);
   ASSERT_FLOAT_EQ(tauM, 0.016634906);
   ASSERT_FLOAT_EQ(tauC, 0.049904719);
 }