Fix #8597: autodoc: metadata only docstring is treated as undocumented

The metadata in docstring is invisible content. Therefore docstring
having only metadata should be treated as undocumented.

CHANGES

@@ -10,6 +10,8 @@ Incompatible changes
 Deprecated
 ----------
 
+* ``sphinx.util.docstrings.extract_metadata()``
+
 Features added
 --------------
 
@@ -22,6 +24,9 @@ Features added
 Bugs fixed
 ----------
 
+* #8597: autodoc: a docsting having metadata only should be treated as
+  undocumented
+
 Testing
 --------
 

doc/extdev/deprecated.rst

@@ -22,6 +22,11 @@ The following is a list of deprecated interfaces.
      - (will be) Removed
      - Alternatives
 
+   * - ``sphinx.util.docstrings.extract_metadata()``
+     - 4.1
+     - 6.0
+     - ``sphinx.util.docstrings.separate_metadata()``
+
    * - ``favicon`` variable in HTML templates
      - 4.0
      - TBD

sphinx/ext/autodoc/__init__.py

@@ -30,7 +30,7 @@ from sphinx.ext.autodoc.mock import ismock, mock, undecorate
 from sphinx.locale import _, __
 from sphinx.pycode import ModuleAnalyzer, PycodeError
 from sphinx.util import inspect, logging
-from sphinx.util.docstrings import extract_metadata, prepare_docstring
+from sphinx.util.docstrings import prepare_docstring, separate_metadata
 from sphinx.util.inspect import (evaluate_signature, getdoc, object_description, safe_getattr,
                                  stringify_signature)
 from sphinx.util.typing import OptionSpec, get_type_hints, restify
@@ -722,9 +722,9 @@ class Documenter:
                 # hack for ClassDocumenter to inject docstring via ObjectMember
                 doc = obj.docstring
 
+            doc, metadata = separate_metadata(doc)
             has_doc = bool(doc)
 
-            metadata = extract_metadata(doc)
             if 'private' in metadata:
                 # consider a member private if docstring has "private" metadata
                 isprivate = True
@@ -1918,7 +1918,7 @@ class DataDocumenter(GenericAliasMixin, NewTypeMixin, TypeVarMixin,
             return True
         else:
             doc = self.get_doc()
-            metadata = extract_metadata('\n'.join(sum(doc, [])))
+            docstring, metadata = separate_metadata('\n'.join(sum(doc, [])))
             if 'hide-value' in metadata:
                 return True
 
@@ -2456,7 +2456,7 @@ class AttributeDocumenter(GenericAliasMixin, NewTypeMixin, SlotsMixin,  # type:
         else:
             doc = self.get_doc()
             if doc:
-                metadata = extract_metadata('\n'.join(sum(doc, [])))
+                docstring, metadata = separate_metadata('\n'.join(sum(doc, [])))
                 if 'hide-value' in metadata:
                     return True
 

sphinx/util/docstrings.py

@@ -11,26 +11,28 @@
 import re
 import sys
 import warnings
-from typing import Dict, List
+from typing import Dict, List, Tuple
 
 from docutils.parsers.rst.states import Body
 
-from sphinx.deprecation import RemovedInSphinx50Warning
+from sphinx.deprecation import RemovedInSphinx50Warning, RemovedInSphinx60Warning
 
 field_list_item_re = re.compile(Body.patterns['field_marker'])
 
 
-def extract_metadata(s: str) -> Dict[str, str]:
-    """Extract metadata from docstring."""
+def separate_metadata(s: str) -> Tuple[str, Dict[str, str]]:
+    """Separate docstring into metadata and others."""
     in_other_element = False
     metadata: Dict[str, str] = {}
+    lines = []
 
     if not s:
-        return metadata
+        return s, metadata
 
     for line in prepare_docstring(s):
         if line.strip() == '':
             in_other_element = False
+            lines.append(line)
         else:
             matched = field_list_item_re.match(line)
             if matched and not in_other_element:
@@ -38,9 +40,20 @@ def extract_metadata(s: str) -> Dict[str, str]:
                 if field_name.startswith('meta '):
                     name = field_name[5:].strip()
                     metadata[name] = line[matched.end():].strip()
+                else:
+                    lines.append(line)
             else:
                 in_other_element = True
+                lines.append(line)
 
+    return '\n'.join(lines), metadata
+
+
+def extract_metadata(s: str) -> Dict[str, str]:
+    warnings.warn("extract_metadata() is deprecated.",
+                  RemovedInSphinx60Warning, stacklevel=2)
+
+    docstring, metadata = separate_metadata(s)
     return metadata
 
 

tests/roots/test-ext-autodoc/target/metadata.py

@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+def foo():
+    """:meta metadata-only-docstring:"""

tests/test_ext_autodoc.py

@@ -735,6 +735,34 @@ def test_autodoc_undoc_members(app):
     ]
 
 
+@pytest.mark.sphinx('html', testroot='ext-autodoc')
+def test_autodoc_undoc_members_for_metadata_only(app):
+    # metadata only member is not displayed
+    options = {"members": None}
+    actual = do_autodoc(app, 'module', 'target.metadata', options)
+    assert list(actual) == [
+        '',
+        '.. py:module:: target.metadata',
+        '',
+    ]
+
+    # metadata only member is displayed when undoc-member given
+    options = {"members": None,
+               "undoc-members": None}
+    actual = do_autodoc(app, 'module', 'target.metadata', options)
+    assert list(actual) == [
+        '',
+        '.. py:module:: target.metadata',
+        '',
+        '',
+        '.. py:function:: foo()',
+        '   :module: target.metadata',
+        '',
+        '   :meta metadata-only-docstring:',
+        '',
+    ]
+
+
 @pytest.mark.sphinx('html', testroot='ext-autodoc')
 def test_autodoc_inherited_members(app):
     options = {"members": None,

tests/test_util_docstrings.py

@@ -8,31 +8,48 @@
     :license: BSD, see LICENSE for details.
 """
 
-from sphinx.util.docstrings import extract_metadata, prepare_commentdoc, prepare_docstring
+from sphinx.util.docstrings import prepare_commentdoc, prepare_docstring, separate_metadata
 
 
-def test_extract_metadata():
-    metadata = extract_metadata(":meta foo: bar\n"
-                                ":meta baz:\n")
+def test_separate_metadata():
+    # metadata only
+    text = (":meta foo: bar\n"
+            ":meta baz:\n")
+    docstring, metadata = separate_metadata(text)
+    assert docstring == ''
     assert metadata == {'foo': 'bar', 'baz': ''}
 
+    # non metadata field list item
+    text = (":meta foo: bar\n"
+            ":param baz:\n")
+    docstring, metadata = separate_metadata(text)
+    assert docstring == ':param baz:\n'
+    assert metadata == {'foo': 'bar'}
+
     # field_list like text following just after paragaph is not a field_list
-    metadata = extract_metadata("blah blah blah\n"
-                                ":meta foo: bar\n"
-                                ":meta baz:\n")
+    text = ("blah blah blah\n"
+            ":meta foo: bar\n"
+            ":meta baz:\n")
+    docstring, metadata = separate_metadata(text)
+    assert docstring == text
     assert metadata == {}
 
     # field_list like text following after blank line is a field_list
-    metadata = extract_metadata("blah blah blah\n"
-                                "\n"
-                                ":meta foo: bar\n"
-                                ":meta baz:\n")
+    text = ("blah blah blah\n"
+            "\n"
+            ":meta foo: bar\n"
+            ":meta baz:\n")
+    docstring, metadata = separate_metadata(text)
+    assert docstring == "blah blah blah\n\n"
     assert metadata == {'foo': 'bar', 'baz': ''}
 
     # non field_list item breaks field_list
-    metadata = extract_metadata(":meta foo: bar\n"
-                                "blah blah blah\n"
-                                ":meta baz:\n")
+    text = (":meta foo: bar\n"
+            "blah blah blah\n"
+            ":meta baz:\n")
+    docstring, metadata = separate_metadata(text)
+    assert docstring == ("blah blah blah\n"
+                         ":meta baz:\n")
     assert metadata == {'foo': 'bar'}